Hand Crafted Pizzas

Our pizzas are 11”-12”, hand stretched and cooked at 800+ degrees for less than 2 minutes in our Italian brick oven. We will gladly remove any items from our classics, but we cannot make additions or substitutions. It just messes with our minds too much. Feel free to build your own if you don’t see something you LOVE already crafted for you.

Classic Red Pizzas

Each classic red pizza comes with San Marzano tomato sauce, pecorino Romano cheese, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil.

Marinara (VE) 

No cheese, extra San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano, garlic, extra virgin olive oil

Margherita (V) 

Fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, basil, olive oil

The Roni

This bad boy is loaded with shredded mozz and pepperoni

Hang Ten

Oregano, ham, pineapple, & fire roasted onion

** For a spicy change of pace, ask for hot peppers instead of onions

Bee Sting

Crushed red pepper, oregano, assorted spicy Italian cured meats, ricotta, & Howell’s  local Honey


Ham, Artichoke, Kalamata Olive, Mushroom, & Basil

Praise the Lard

Basil, oregano, spicy salami, house-made sweet Italian sausage, & pancetta (Italian bacon)

The Godfather

House-made sweet Italian sausage, cup-and-char pepperoni, sliced meatballs, provolone, mushrooms

Classic White Pizzas

Each classic white pizza comes with extra virgin olive oil, pecorino Romano cheese, & fresh mozzarella.

Popeye (V)

Spinach, artichoke, provolone, garlic, & lemon

Sweet Italian

House-made sweet Italian sausage & fire roasted onion

Sunshine in My Soul (V)

Sweet basil, thinly sliced lemons, & a sprinkle of raw sugar

Che Figata! (V) 

Provolone, Gorgonzola (Italian blue cheese), fig spread, & balsamic (no sauce)

** Add imported Prosciutto di Parma $3

Spud Harvest

House-made sweet Italian sausage, potato, rosemary, baby arugula, finely grated Parmesan

Build Your Own Pizza

Comes with shredded mozzarella, Romano cheese, and extra virgin olive oil

1. Choose your base

   San Marzano tomato sauce

   Extra virgin olive oil

   Basil Pesto

2. Add your toppings

We recommend no more than 3 toppings.




Fresh mozzarella



Black olive

Fire roasted onion

Jalapeno peppers




Sweet Red Peppers







Prosciutto di Parma

Spicy salami

Sweet Italian Sausage, made in-house


Focaccia Bread

Oregano and pecorino Romano, with Marinara dipping sauce

Cheesy garlic bread

Shredded mozzarella, fresh cut garlic, olive oil and oregano, with Marinara dipping sauce


Fresca (V)

Fresh baby arugula, mixed greens, strawberries, finely grated Parmesan, candied nuts with sweet balsamic reduction

Hail Caesar

Romaine, Parmesan, pancetta and Caesar dressing on a fresh baked focaccia

The Italian Job 

Mixed greens, provolone, fresh mozzarella, finely grated Parmesan, pancetta, pepperoni, ham, tomatoes, black olives, onion, pepperoncini topped with a sweet balsamic reduction


Traditional Italian flatbread baked, split and stuffed with goodness, then fired in our brick oven to make it hot and crispy on the outside, melty and yummy on the inside. Available for lunch only. 

Meatball marinara

Meatball, Provolone, pecorino Romano, San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano

Cotto Ham

Ham, fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, fresh sliced tomatoes, arugula

Sausage & Potato

House-made sweet Italian sausage, pecorino Romano, potato, fresh mozzarella, arugula

Artichoke & Tomato (V)

Artichoke heart, oregano, fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, fresh sliced tomatoes, arugula

The Garden (VE)

Mushroom, potato, red peppers, fire roasted red onion, fresh sliced tomatoes, arugula, San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano


Family-style. These desserts serve 2 - 6 people. Each is made with our Italian sourdough pizza crust.

Hot Mess (V)

Cream, raw sugar, Nutella & powdered sugar. 

Star Witness (V) 

Stunning star-shaped creation with Nutella, cream, and raw sugar baked to perfection and then drizzled with warm Nutella and sprinkled with Powdered sugar.

Katie Kay (V) 

Berry compote, fresh seasonal berries, whipped ricotta cream, and powdered sugar.


Pepsi products

San Pellegrino

Mexican Coke

Don’t Miss out! Join our Fan Club
to stay up to date on the latest and greatest exclusive deals.



 175 W. 200 S., #100 | 208.269.9885 | info@righteousslice.com

HOURS:    Mon-Thur 11AM to 9PM, Fri-Sat 11AM to 10PM     |   CLOSED SUNDAY

208.820.4597   |   INFO@RIGHTEOUSSLICE.COM
175 W. 200 S. #100, REXBURG, ID 83440
Join The Team